When it comes to finding the perfect sweet treat to complement a juicy burger, nothing hits the spot like one of our handcrafted shakes. At our Pigeon Forge restaurant, we serve up some of the richest, creamiest, and most satisfying shakes that have become fan favorites among locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re looking for a nostalgic classic or a shake loaded with indulgent mix-ins, our menu has something to satisfy every craving.

The Classics: Vanilla, Strawberry, and Chocolate

Nothing beats the simplicity of a classic shake. Made with Hershey’s old-fashioned vanilla, strawberry, or milk chocolate ice cream, these shakes are timeless and delicious. Each sip delivers a smooth and creamy experience, bringing back memories of traditional diners where shakes were a must-have with every meal. If you’re looking for a tried-and-true shake that pairs perfectly with any burger, these classic flavors will never disappoint.

For those who love variety, you can even mix flavors to create your own signature blend. A swirl of vanilla and chocolate creates a delightful balance of rich and creamy, while a combination of strawberry and vanilla gives a fruity and refreshing twist. No matter your preference, these classic shakes are always a go-to option.

The Fluffernutter: A Nostalgic Favorite

If you’re a fan of peanut butter and marshmallow, the Fluffernutter shake is a must-try. This delightful shake is made with Hershey’s old-fashioned vanilla ice cream, peanut butter, and marshmallow cream, creating a perfectly balanced blend of sweet and salty flavors. Inspired by the iconic Fluffernutter sandwich, this shake takes things to the next level by combining thick, creamy ice cream with the nutty richness of peanut butter and the gooey sweetness of marshmallow.

The Fluffernutter is perfect for those who love unique and indulgent flavors.

Strawberry Banana: A Fruity Delight

For a refreshing twist on a traditional shake, our Strawberry Banana shake is the way to go. Made with Hershey’s strawberry ice cream and fresh banana, this shake is a vibrant and flavorful treat that offers a perfect balance of fruity sweetness. The natural creaminess of banana enhances the smooth texture of the shake, making it both delicious and satisfying.

This shake is a great choice for those who want something slightly lighter but still incredibly indulgent.

Cookies & Cream: A Crunchy, Creamy Dream

For cookie lovers, the Cookies & Cream shake is an absolute must-try. This shake features Hershey’s old-fashioned vanilla, chocolate, or mint ice cream as a base, blended with chunks of Oreo cookies for the ultimate creamy and crunchy combination. Every sip is filled with bits of chocolatey cookie goodness, making this shake an irresistible choice for dessert lovers.

The Cookies & Cream shake is one of our most popular options, and for good reason—it’s a decadent, velvety shake with just the right amount of cookie crunch.

Reese Cup: A Peanut Butter Lover’s Dream

Peanut butter and chocolate have always been a match made in heaven, and our Reese Cup shake is the ultimate proof. Made with Hershey’s old-fashioned vanilla ice cream, peanut butter, and chunks of Reese’s cups, this shake delivers a perfect combination of rich, nutty, and chocolatey flavors.

The Reese Cup shake is a dream come true for peanut butter lovers, offering a thick and creamy texture with the signature taste of Reese’s in every sip.

The Ultimate Experience for Shake Lovers

If you’re looking for the best shakes in Pigeon Forge, our menu is packed with options that cater to every craving. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic vanilla shake, a crunchy Cookies & Cream, or a decadent Reese Cup shake, we have something for everyone. Pair your shake with one of our specialty burgers, or stop by for a sweet treat on its own.

For those looking to enjoy our shakes at home, we offer convenient catering options so you can bring the indulgence to your next event. Whether you're dining in or ordering for a special occasion, our handcrafted shakes are always a hit.

Got a Question? Let’s Chat!

Still wondering which shake to try first? Have a question about our menu? We’d love to hear from you! Get in touch with us today and let us help you find your new favorite shake. Reach out to us here.

FAQs on Our Most Popular Shakes You Cannot Miss

1. What makes your shakes different from others?

Our shakes are made with premium Hershey’s ice cream and fresh ingredients, ensuring a rich and creamy texture that stands out from the rest.

2. Can I customize my shake?

Yes! You can mix flavors, add extra toppings, or request adjustments to make your shake uniquely yours.

3. Are your shakes available for delivery?

Yes! You can enjoy our delicious shakes from the comfort of your home. Check out our menu to place an order.

4. Do you have dairy-free options?

At this time, our shakes are made with dairy-based ice cream. However, we’re always exploring new options to accommodate different dietary needs.

5. What’s the best shake to pair with a burger?

The Cookies & Cream shake is a fan-favorite alongside any of our juicy burgers, but it all depends on your taste preferences!

6. Are your shakes made with real fruit?

Yes! Our Strawberry Banana shake is made with fresh bananas and Hershey’s strawberry ice cream for an authentic fruity taste.

7. Do you offer catering for shakes?

Yes! Our catering services allow you to bring our famous shakes to your next event.

8. What’s your most popular shake?

The Reese Cup shake is one of our top sellers, thanks to its rich peanut butter and chocolate combination.

9. How large are your shakes?

Our shakes are generously portioned to provide the perfect amount of indulgence in every serving.

10. Can I order a shake to-go?

Absolutely! All of our shakes are available for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.

‍